Photo by bedneyimages
The idea of Christian perfectionism is a heavy burden to willingly take. Many believers feel as though they must be perfect to please God–and do nothing short of perfection in their ways to showcase and affirm their faith.
They think they must follow every rule without fail.
This is a quick way that leads to guilt, exhaustion, and a feeling that you are never good enough.
But the truth is clear: Christian perfectionism is a myth. Human perfection is impossible. The Bible and personal stories, like Ashley D. Wille’s in My Journey Through the Cross, show us a better way.
That way is to rest in God’s perfect love, because He alone is perfect.
The Heavy Yoke of Christian Perfectionism
Christian perfectionism is the fruit of a misunderstanding: the false belief that we must earn God’s love by being flawless in every way. Ashley Wille describes this struggle as she wrote about trying to meet impossible standards, feeling that she had to “perform to a certain spiritual standard… in order to be and stay pleasing to God.”
This is the false core of Christian perfectionism: it makes faith a labor of our work and not a reflection of God’s grace.
This mindset creates what we may call a toxic faith, where belief in a list of duties that one commits. Thence, faith becomes a source of fear, not love: you live worried that one mistake will cut you off from God.
Ashley felt this keenly.
“I lived accordingly, with lingering guilt for not making the standard of holiness.”
Photo by jcomp
Why Perfection is Impossible for People
The Bible is clear about the nature of man, with Romans 3:23 saying that “for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.”
Everyone missed the mark. No one is perfect. Everyone always misses. No one can be perfect.
Ashley looked at this from another perspective: even on her best behavior, she “would not … make it to the bottom of the scale of God’s holiness.” This brought her catharsis.
Christian perfectionism ignores a key fact: we are born into a broken world, with a nature that tends to choose the wrong thing.
Ashley explains that trying to be perfect is like eating from “the tree of knowledge of good and evil.” You learn right from wrong, but you don’t get the power to do right. It becomes “a never-ending cycle of defeat.” This cycle is the reality of Christian perfectionism: a promise of holiness that will only ever deliver frustration.
The Cost of Reaching Out to Perfection
Trying to be perfect is exhausting. It leads directly to spiritual burnout.
Ashley describes years of striving, only to be followed by hitting “a cycle of frustration on a plateau of status-quo faith, from which I could not seem to ascend.”
This is spiritual burnout: you give all your energy to spiritual performance, but you feel empty and stuck at the end of it all.
Spiritual burnout happens when your faith is fueled by your own effort instead of God’s Spirit. It’s like trying to light a lamp with a dead battery. Ashley compares it to “Martha in Luke 10,” who was “worried and upset about many things” while trying to serve Jesus. She was busy for God but not resting in God.
Christian perfectionism makes us all Marthas: busy, worried, and burned out. Therefore, Jesus invites us, like Mary, to sit at His feet and simply receive His love. That is the cure for burning out the spirit.
Embracing Your Spiritual Struggle Within Grace
Every believer faces spiritual struggle. We all have areas where we fail. Christian perfectionism tells us to hide these struggles in shame because if you fail, how can you be worthy of God? If you were a good Christian, you wouldn’t even be having this problem.
But God’s grace meets us in the struggle all the same.
Ashley learned that even in her anger and pain, God welcomed her until finally, she poured out her rage to God, and His response was gentle: “Do you feel better now?”
She learned that “[nothing she] could ever do, no matter how crazy, could ever separate [her] from His love.”
Your spiritual struggle will not shock God or push Him away from you. It is simply an opportunity to experience His grace more deeply. Ashley writes that “our hidden wounds must be acknowledged and surrendered in order for Him to heal them.”
We don’t have to be perfect to come to God.
Because we go to Him in our imperfection to be made whole.
The Path Forward: Rest, Not Striving
The Bible invites us to a place of rest. Hebrews 4:9-11 says, “There remains, then, a Sabbath-rest for the people of God; for anyone who enters God’s rest also rests from their works… Let us, therefore, make every effort to enter that rest.”
This might sound odd: make an effort to rest.
But it is the truth to trust in God, meaning we must actively stop trying to save ourselves and trust what Christ has done.
Ashley calls this “The Sabbath Rest.”
It is the end of Christian perfectionism: giving up the exhausting work of self-improvement and letting God’s finished work be enough.
“I declare my useless work… in trying to please God… completely finished. I rest in His one and only finished sin payment.”
This rest is the heart of grace-based living, trusting that God’s love, not your perfection, is what holds you firm.
Photo by wirestock
Letting Go of the Myth
Christian perfectionism is a painful illusion. It promises a closer walk with God but builds a wall of guilt and fear, and leads to spiritual burnout and toxic faith.
The true path of spiritual maturity is realizing that our spiritual struggle is daily, and God’s grace is sufficient for it.
As Ashley Wille’s powerful journey shows, freedom is found not in trying harder, but in trusting more, not in our perfect performance, but in God’s perfect love. He alone is perfect.
Our calling is not to mimic a perfection we cannot achieve, but to abide in the love of the only One who is perfect.
Discover more in Ashley D. Wille’s book, My Journey Through the Cross.
